How reasonable is it to expect an employee to work for us, and us alone? As employers, should we ask employees to commit to our business full-time and wholeheartedly, or is it okay for them to have a side hustle? What about if they’re moonlighting, and performing two jobs on a full-time basis?
Moonlighting – or working two full-time jobs simultaneously – has recently become a more common practice, coinciding with the rise of both the cost of living and remote working. With remote work giving people the option to choose flexible hours, it’s not uncommon for them to take on two jobs.
What stance should employers take on this practice? Is it illegal or unethical?
According to Fair Work, it depends on the nature of the employee’s contract and whether the side business or secondary work competes or otherwise interferes with it. Unless employees have signed a non-compete agreement or exclusivity contract, there’s technically nothing unlawful about the practice.
Let’s take a look at some recent examples. The Fair Work Commission upheld the dismissal of financial adviser who was conducting a side business offering financial services similar to the operations of his primary employer.
On the contrary, the dismissal of an employee who was performing driving work while on annual leave from his primary job, was considered unfair by the FWC. In this case, there was no evidence that the driver’s work for the client would have otherwise been given to his employer and he did not perform the work on his employer’s time.
For the most part, moonlighting or side hustles are only problematic when they impact employee performance or represent a safety risk due to fatigue or distraction, or if the secondary employment encroaches on the employer’s business.
If an employer suspects that an employee is conducting a side business or moonlighting, they should assess the nature of the conduct, and whether it amounts to grounds for disciplinary action.
Typically, Australian employment law protects an employee’s right to carry on a business or engage in other work as long as:
- The employee is not in competition with their employer’s business
- They do not use their employer’s property
- There are no implications for the employee’s or anyone else’s health and safety
As long your employee is meeting their deadlines, completing their tasks and performing well, there shouldn’t be an issue with side hustles and moonlighting. As always, it’s about being open, honest and keeping the lines of communication open.
Be clear about your expectations from your employees from the outset and, as always, get in touch with the HR Dept to help with policies and procedures.